Optimization of thermoelectric properties of n-type Bi2(Te,Se)3 with optimizing ball milling time
来源期刊:Rare Metals2018年第4期
论文作者:Ji-Hee Son Min-Wook Oh Bong-Seo Kim Su-Dong Park
文章页码:351 - 359
摘 要:The thermoelectric properties at elevated temperature were investigated for n-type Bi2(Te,Se)3 which is obtained from ball milling processed powder with various milling times. Electrical properties such as electrical resistivity and Seebeck coefficient are clearly dependent on milling time, in which the carrier concentration is attributed to the change of the electrical properties. The concentrations of the defects are also varied with the ball milling time, which is the origin of the carrier concentration variation. Even though finer grain sizes are obtained after the long ball milling time, the temperature dependence of the thermal conductivity is not solely understood with the grain size, whereas the electrical contribution to the thermal conductivity should be also considered. The highest figure of merit value of ZT = 0.83 is achieved at373 K for the optimized samples, in which ball milling time is 10 h. The obtained ZT value is 48% improvement over that of the 0.5-h sample at 373 K.
稀有金属(英文版) 2018,37(04),351-359
Ji-Hee Son Min-Wook Oh Bong-Seo Kim Su-Dong Park
Thermoelectric Conversion Research Center, Korea Electrotechnology Research Institute
Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Hanbat National University
收稿日期:31 December 2017
基金:supported by the research fund of Hanbat National University in 2015;
Ji-Hee Son Min-Wook Oh Bong-Seo Kim Su-Dong Park
Thermoelectric Conversion Research Center, Korea Electrotechnology Research Institute
Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Hanbat National University
Abstract:
The thermoelectric properties at elevated temperature were investigated for n-type Bi2(Te,Se)3 which is obtained from ball milling processed powder with various milling times. Electrical properties such as electrical resistivity and Seebeck coefficient are clearly dependent on milling time, in which the carrier concentration is attributed to the change of the electrical properties. The concentrations of the defects are also varied with the ball milling time, which is the origin of the carrier concentration variation. Even though finer grain sizes are obtained after the long ball milling time, the temperature dependence of the thermal conductivity is not solely understood with the grain size, whereas the electrical contribution to the thermal conductivity should be also considered. The highest figure of merit value of ZT = 0.83 is achieved at373 K for the optimized samples, in which ball milling time is 10 h. The obtained ZT value is 48% improvement over that of the 0.5-h sample at 373 K.
Keyword:
Thermoelectric properties; Ball milling; Bi2Te3; Seebeck coefficient; Grain size; Thermal conductivity;
Author: Min-Wook Oh e-mail: mwoh@hanbat.ac.kr;
Received: 31 December 2017
1 Introduction
A thermoelectric conversion technology has attracted attention due to power generation ability from recovering waste heat
Bismuth telluride-based compounds are widely used in thermoelectric devices due to their excellent thermoelectric properties at room temperature region
In this study,the effect of ball milling time on the microstructures and thermoelectric properties of the n-type Bi2(Te,Se)3 compounds was investigated.The powder was obtained with planetary ball miller.The thermoelectric properties were investigated within the temperature range between 298 and 573 K.The investigated properties were understood with the change of the microstructures and carrier concentration.The variation of the properties with respect to the ball milling time was compared with that of p-type (Bi,Sb)2Te3 previously studied.
2 Experimental
The ball milling process was identical with that of p-type(Bi,Sb)2Te3
The phase of the samples was determined by X-ray diffractometer (XRD,X'pert PRO,PANalytical) at room temperature with Cu Kαradiation (λ=0.15406 nm),from which the lattice parameters of all samples were obtained with Rietveld analysis implemented in the HighScore Plus program (PANalytical).Scanning electron microscope(SEM,S-4800,Hitachi) was used to investigate the fractured surfaces of the samples.Inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometer (ICP-OES,Optima 5300DV,PerkinElmer Inc.) was used to analyze the composition of the samples.The starting materials show the composition of about Bi1.94Sb0.01Te2.76Se0.29.In this research,the composition of the samples was denoted as Bi2(Te,Se)3.
3 Results and discussion
Figure 1 shows XRD patterns of the consolidated Bi2(Te,Se)3 specimens fabricated by SPS.XRD patterns agree with the standard powder diffraction of the Bi2Te3-related compounds with the crystal structure of
whereβis the integral breadth of the diffraction peak,λis the wavelength of X-ray,d is the average grain size,θis the Bragg diffraction angle,andεis the microscopic strain.
Fig.1 XRD patterns of bulk n-type Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples consoli-dated by SPS
Fig.2 Estimated grain size of n-type Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples obtained with Williamson-Hall equation (Williamson-Hall plots for samples being presented in supplementary file)
Figure 2 shows the estimated grain size of the samples as a function of ball milling time.The grain size decreases as the milling time increases up to 10 h.However,the trend of the grain size variation shows much difference in the samples after 24 h.The grain size increases in the sample after 24 h and then decreases again with milling time increasing.These differences in the sample after the larger milling time seem to be due to the mechanism of the highenergy ball milling in which the repetitions of fracturing and welding of particles are performed
SEM images of the fractured surface of the samples after0.5-,5.0-,10.0-,and 48.0-h ball milling are shown in Fig.3.It can be concluded that the grain size is relatively large in the samples with small milling time,which is in accordance with the conclusions from XRD pattern analysis.The direct comparison of the grain sizes between the values estimated by XRD and SEM is not rational,because the values from XRD analysis represent the grain sizes of the sub-grains and are generally smaller than those of the milling time at room temperature microscopy such as SEM and TEM
Fig.3 SEM images of fractured surface of n-type Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples obtained from ball-milled powders for milling time of a 0.5 h,b 5 h,c 10 h,and d 48 h
Fig.4 Temperature dependence of electrical resistivity of Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples with different milling time
Fig.5 Temperature dependence of Seebeck coefficient of Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples with different milling time
The temperature dependence of the electrical resistivity and the Seebeck coefficient of the samples is shown in Figs.4 and 5.The electrical resistivity increases with the temperature in the whole temperature range,which is a behavior of the highly degenerated semiconductor.The electrical resistivity increases as the milling time increases up to 10.0 h,whereas the values of the 24.0-and 48.0-h samples are smaller than that of the 10.0-h samples.The absolute values of the Seebeck coefficient are also maximized in the 10.0-h samples,and then the values are decreased in the 24.0-and 48.0-h samples.The milling time dependence of the grain size also shows the change of the variation after 10 h.In the fabrication process,this milling time seems to be the critical turning point of the properties.The electrical resistivity is related to the carrier concentration and the mobility.The smaller grain sizes will decrease the mobility due to the grain boundary scattering.Thus,the larger electrical resistivity in 10.0-,24.0-,and48.0-h samples may be due to the smaller grain sizes,which will be justified below.However,in order to confirm the origin of the change of the electrical resistivity,the carrier concentration should be also investigated.Moreover,the Seebeck coefficient is also largely dependent on the carrier concentration.Thus,the carrier concentration was estimated with the Hall coefficient measurement.
The estimated carrier concentration at 298 K is shown in Fig.6 as a function of the milling time.The value of the carrier concentration (n) is related to the Hall coefficient(RH) by following equation:
where q is a charge of the carrier and AH is a constant which depends on the scattering mechanism,the mobility(μ)ratio between electrons and holes,etc.
Table 1 Measured values of carrier concentration,mobility,density,and relative density at room temperature (theoretical density of Bi2Te37.80 g·cm-3 being used in estimation of relative density)
where kB is the Boltzmann's constant and h is the Plank's constant
In order to check the effect of the effective mass,the Seebeck coefficient at 298 K is plotted in Fig.7 as a function of the carrier concentration (a so-called Pisarenko plot).The values of the effective mass are only varied from1.1m0 to 1.3m0,where m0 is the rest mass of an electron.Thus,the carrier concentration is largely varied with the milling time and mainly affects the electrical resistivity and the Seebeck coefficient.It may be stressed that the effect of the grain boundary on the electrical resistivity would exist as mentioned before,but the variation of the electrical resistivity with the milling time is mainly attributed to the change of the carrier concentration.
The change of the carrier concentration is confirmed in results and discussion of the electrical properties.Therefore,the origin of the variation of the carrier concentration should be investigated.It is known that the carrier concentration of the n-type Bi2Te3 is determined with the antisite defects
Fig.7 Plot of Seebeck coefficient versus carrier concentration for Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples with different milling time (each solid line representing calculated Seebeck coefficient with Eq.(3) as effective mass increased by 0.1 m0;inset showing carrier concentration of samples with different milling time at room temperature,from which milling time for each point in the main plot can be easily assigned)
Fig.8 Lattice parameters of Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples with different milling time
If TeBi is formed in the lattices,the lattice parameters will decrease,because the atomic radii of Bi and Te are 1.6and 1.4,respectively
As well as the major n-type antisite defects,the minor ptype antisite defects can be considered.The BiTe antisite defects are a major p-type antisite defects
If the concentration of BiTe ([BiTe]) increases,the lattice parameters will increase due to the larger atomic radius of Bi and the concentration of holes also increases,meaning the reduction of the electrons concentration.Moreover,[BiTe]will increase as[VTe]increases.The increment in[BiTe]will also introduce the reduction of[TeBi].Therefore,the increment in[BiTe]can explain properly all observed properties,as done with the reduction of[TeBi].Conclusively,it can be insisted that the reduction of the electron concentration is attributed to the change of the antisite defects concentration:reduction of[TeBi]or increment in[BiTe].
The increment in electrons concentration for larger milling time (24.0 and 48.0 h) may be due to the unintentional doping of Fe.Because the steel jar and balls were used in the milling process,the samples may be contaminated by Fe
The power factor (S2/ρ) of the samples is shown in Fig.9 as a function of the temperature.The value for 10.0-h sample is the largest at low temperature (2.40×10-3W·m-1·K-2 at 323 K),which is mainly due to the largest Seebeck coefficient among the samples.It is well known that the power factor is maximized at the specific carrier concentration
Figure 10 shows temperature dependence of the thermal conductivity of the samples as a function of the milling time.The values for the samples with smaller milling time(0.5-5.0 h) show relatively large values at room temperature compared with the samples with larger milling time.However,as the temperature increases,the behavior is varied and quite different from that of the samples with low temperature,especially the behavior of the sample after10.0 h is peculiar.In order to understand these,the thermal conductivity is pided into electrical thermal conductivity(κe) and phonon thermal conductivity (κp),because the total thermal conductivity (κ) is a sum ofκe andκp (κ=κe+κp).κe can be estimated with Wiedemann-Franz equation,κe=qLT,in which L is the Lorenz number whose value is dependent on the Fermi energy,the scattering mechanism,etc.
Fig.9 Temperature dependence of power factor of Bi2(Te,Se)3samples with different milling time
Fig.10 Temperature dependence of thermal conductivity of Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples with different milling time
whereλis the scattering factor in which acoustic phonon scattering and ionized impurity scattering corresponds toλ=0 andλ=2,respectively,ηis the reduced Fermienergy and
Because the considered temperature is much higher than the Debye temperature,it is assumed that the acoustic phonon scattering is a dominant scattering mechanism and the value ofλ=0 is used in the estimation of L andη.The difference between Eq.(3) and Eq.7 is that the latter is derived with Fermi-Dirac statistic in the Boltzmann transport equation,whereas the former is with the Boltzmann statistic for the highly degenerated scheme.The single carrier is assumed to fit the measured Seebeck coefficient with Eq.(7),as assumed in the calculation of the carrier concentration.The obtained L of the samples is shown in Fig.11 as a function of the temperature.The sample after 0.5 h shows the largest value of L at room temperature,whereas the sample after 10.0 h shows the smallest value.In the degenerated semiconductor scheme,a small value of the Fermi energy in Eq.(6) gives a small value of L.It is notable that the value of L is determined by the Fermi energy which also determines the carrier concentration.Therefore,the estimated L exhibits the similar milling time dependence compared with that of the carrier concentration.
The temperature dependence of the lattice thermal conductivity obtained using the estimated L is shown in Fig.12.It is well known thatκp decreases as temperature increases when phonon scattering is dominant.However,the positive temperature coefficient ofκp(dκp/dT) is observed at high temperature for all samples.This positive coefficient ofκp at high temperature is believed to be due to the bipolar transport
Fig.11 Temperature dependence of Lorentz number of Bi2(Te,Se)3samples
Fig.12 Temperature dependence of lattice thermal conductivity of Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples obtained using estimated Lorenz number
Fig.13 Temperature dependence of ZT of Bi2(Te,Se)3 samples with different milling time
Figure 13 shows the temperature dependence of ZT of all the samples.The highest value of ZT=0.83 is achieved for the 10.0-h samples,which is about 48%enhancement over that of 0.5-h sample at 373 K.The Seebeck coefficient and the reduced thermal conductivity contribute to the enhanced ZT.It is clearly seen that the value of ZT is much dependent on milling time.The change of ZT in the p-type samples after the varied milling time is only about 10%.Thus,the fabrication process optimization is much more crucial for the n-type Bi2(Te,Se)3 compounds than for the p-type Bi0.5Sb1.5Te3 compounds.
4 Conclusion
The thermoelectric properties and the microstructure of Bi2(Te,Se)3 were investigated as a function of the ball milling times.The reduction of the grain size with the ball milling times was clearly demonstrated via microscopy images and the estimation from XRD patterns.As well as the change in the grain size,the thermoelectric properties were also investigated after various ball milling times.The electrical resistivity and the Seebeck coefficient are clearly changed with the milling time,and there was optimum milling time to maximize the power factor.The change of the electrical properties is attributed to the variation of the carrier concentration.The thermal conductivity is largely affected by the electrical properties,rather than by the grain sizes,which is different from that of the p-type Bi0.5Sb1.5Te3 compounds.The maximum ZT of 0.83 at373 K is achieved in 10-h samples,and the obtained ZT value for 10 h has a 48%improvement over the ZT value of the 0.5-h sample at 373 K.
Acknowledgements This research was supported by the research fund of Hanbat National University in 2015.
参考文献
[1] Snyder GJ,Toberer ES.Complex thermoelectric materials.Nat Mater.2008;7(2):105.
[2] Sales BC.Thermoelectric materials.Small is cooler.Science.2002;295(5558):1248.
[24] Slater JC.Atomic radii in crystals.J Chem Phys.1964;41(10):3199.
[31] Parrot JE,Stucks AD.Thermal Conductivity of Solids.London:Pion Limited;1975.44.