Rare Metals2017年第11期

Electronic transport and magnetic performance of Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses

Hai-Bin Wang Qing Wang Chong-Lin Chen Chuang Dong

School of Materials Science and Engineering, Jiangsu University of Science and Technology

School of Materials Science and Engineering, Dalian University of Technology

Department of Physics and Astronomy,University of Texas at San Antonio

收稿日期:14 February 2014

基金:financially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No.51171035);the Doctor Research Start-Up Funding of Jiangsu University of Science and Technology (No.1062921406);

Electronic transport and magnetic performance of Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses

Hai-Bin Wang Qing Wang Chong-Lin Chen Chuang Dong

School of Materials Science and Engineering, Jiangsu University of Science and Technology

School of Materials Science and Engineering, Dalian University of Technology

Department of Physics and Astronomy,University of Texas at San Antonio

Abstract:

The electronic transport and magnetic performances of Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses under low temperature were investigated. X-ray diffraction(XRD) analysis indicates that the Ni-Nb-Zr ribbons prepared by induction melting and melt spinning method have single amorphous phase. The electrical transport property results of these metallic glass alloys indicate that the Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses have negative resistivity temperature coefficients(RTC) and lowtemperature drift. The negative RTC and corresponding possible values of Fermi energy of Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses are interpreted by the extended Ziman-Faber diffraction theory.The magnetic measurements indicate that the magnetic intensities of the Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses are related to Ni content and atomic sizes while the low temperature has few influences on the magnetic properties.

Keyword:

Metallic glass; Electrical resistance; Magnetic properties;

Author: Hai-Bin Wang haibin666666@163.com;

Received: 14 February 2014

1 Introduction

Since the discovery of quasicrystals by Shechtman,amorphous and quasicrystalline materials of metastable phase alloys have been rapidly developed [ 1, 2, 3, 4] .Recently,Nibased metallic glasses have attracted great attention due to their excellent mechanical and chemical properties [ 5, 6, 7, 8, 9] .Ni-Nb and Ni-Zr systems such as Ni-Nb-Sn alloys [ 7] and Ni-Zr-Y-Al alloys [ 10] were found to have good glassforming ability (GFA) and better mechanical properties than traditional Ni-based metallic glasses.The goldschmidt atomic radii of Ni,Nb,and Zr are 0.128,0.146,and0.160 nm,respectively,which is in good agreement with Miracle'efficient cluster packing model [ 11] .As the result,the ternary Ni-Nb-Zr system becomes a good candidate for the development of new Ni-base bulk metallic glass (BMGs) with higher GFA and better mechanical properties.

In the ternary Ni-Nb-Zr phase diagram,many metallic glass compositions were found [ 9, 12] .Yamaura et al. [ 13] reported the fabrication of a 20-mm-width and 40-μmthickness ribbon with (Ni0.6Nb0.4)100-xZrx (x=0,20,30,40,and 50;at%) to study the hydrogen permeation.It was found that the permeability of the Ni-Nb-Zr amorphous alloys significantly increased with Zr content and temperature.The recent research [ 14] using the cluster-plusglue-atom model [ 15, 16] and a eutectic-related binary cluster M-Ni6Nb6 (M=0.5 Ni+0.5 Nb) derived from a eutectic phase Ni7Nb6 (Fe7W6 type) shows that the alloy rods with 3 mm in diameter and single glassy phase of these compositions are successfully achieved.A series of the new chemical compositions of[M-Ni6Nb4MZr]Ni3alloys were designed,such as[M-Ni6Nb5-xMZrx]Ni3(x=0.76,0.84,0.92,1.00,1.08,1.16).In addition to the studies of mechanical properties and chemical stability of these new types of metallic glasses,studies on electrical transport property of these metallic glasses show many interesting and anomalous physical phenomena [ 17, 18] .One of the most interesting phenomena is that such alloys with amorphous structure can have either a positive or a negative resistivity temperature coefficient (RTC).In this research,four different composition alloys were fabricated,including the Ni-rich composition Ni63.29Nb31.65Zr5.06,two new designed compositions Ni62.5Nb32.75Zr4.75 ([M-Ni6Nb4.24MZr0.76]Ni3) and Ni62.5Nb31.25Zr6.25 ([M-Ni6Nb4MZr1]Ni3) using cluster-plus-glue-atom model [ 14] ,and one Zr-rich composition Ni48Nb32Zr20 for the development of hydrogen permeation materials [ 13] .The resistances as the function of temperature were studied to understand the electronic transport behavior.Furthermore,the effects of compositions as well as temperature on the magnetic properties of these alloys were analyzed to fully understand the Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses.

2 Experimental

Master ingots with compositions of Ni63.29Nb31.65Zr5.06,Ni62.5Nb32.75Zr4.75 ([M-Ni6Nb4.24MZr0.76]Ni3),Ni62.5Nb31.25Zr6.25([M-Ni6Nb4MZr1]Ni3),and Ni48Nb32Zr20 were first prepared by arc melting the mixtures of the constituent elements under argon atmosphere.The purities of the elements are 99.99 wt%for Ni,99.99 wt%for Zr,and 99.95 wt%for Nb,respectively.The ingots were remelted three times to improve compositional homogeneity.Then,these master ingots were remelted by induction melting in a quartz tube,and ribbon samples with width of 2-3 mm and thickness of 20-30μm were produced by a single roller melting-spinning apparatus at a wheel surface velocity of 50 m·s-1.X-ray diffraction (XRD) with Cu Kαradiation (λ=0.15406 nm) was employed to study the crystallinity of these alloys.The electrical resistances of these ribbons in the temperature range of77-293 K were measured by a standard four-point method using the Lake Shore 370 AC resistance bridge.Liquid nitrogen was used to cooling down the ribbons to 77 K.Magnetic measurements were taken using a Quantum design physical property measurement systems(PPMS-9 system) with a vibrating sample magnetometer(VSM) at room temperature and low temperature cooled by liquid helium.

3 Results and discussion

3.1 Structural analysis

Figure 1 shows the typical XRD patterns of the as-prepared Ni63.29Nb31.65Zr5.06,Ni62.5Nb32.75Zr4.75,Ni62.5Nb31.25Zr6.25,and Ni48Nb32Zr22 ribbons.The XRD patterns of the first three samples with richer Ni contents show wide diffused peaks near 42°and no detectable crystalline peaks,indicating that all of these three samples have fully amorphous phases.The lower Ni content alloy Ni48Nb32Zr20 also has a fully amorphous phase,but its amorphous peak shifts left obviously due to its larger average atomic radius.

Fig.1 XRD patterns of Ni-Nb-Zr ribbons with different compositions

3.2 Electronic transport properties

The electrical resistances of the ribbon samples as a function of temperature are shown in Fig.2a.All ribbon samples of Ni-Nb-Zr alloys exhibit negative RTC over the entire temperature range of 77-293 K.As shown in Fig.2b,the magnitudes of the resistances increase by2.0%-3.5%from room temperature to the boiling point of liquid nitrogen.Using this formula,

where RTCave is the average resistivity temperature coefficient,Rmax is the maximum resistance of a sample,Rmin is its minimum resistance,andΔT is the temperature difference,their average RTCs can be obtained:90×10-6-162×10-6 K-1.The values are much smaller than those of most pure metals,such as Ni:~0.05 K-1,Zr:~0.003 K-1.and Pt:~0.002 K-1 [ 19] .By means of heat treatment to produce part crystallization phase in metallic glass,it is possible to bring the value of RTC of ribbon metallic glasses further close to zero like BMGs [ 20] .So the ribbon samples of Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses possess the prospects to become candidate for low-temperature drift resistor used at low temperature because of their negative and small RTC.

Although various models were developed to understand the electric transport properties of metallic glasses,the Ziman-Faber diffraction model is usually adopted [ 21, 22, 23] by assuming a nearly free electron (NFE) model based on the Boltzmann equation.For metallic glasses containing transition elements,the formula of resistivity (ρ(T)) is as follows [ 24, 25, 26] :

Fig.2 Temperature dependence of resistance of Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glass ribbons in temperature range of 77-293 K a and ratio of resistances at boiling point of liquid nitrogen and room temperature b

where h is the reduced Planck constant,m is the mass of a electron,e is the electric charge of a electron,kF is the Fermi wave number,EF is the Fermi energy,Ωis the atomic volume,η2(EF) is the d-partial-wave phase shift describing the scattering of the conduction electrons by the ion cores which carry a muffin-tin potential centered on each ion position,S0(2kF) is the structure factor at T=0 K and scattering factor K=2kF,and W is the DebyeWaller factor.

Using Eq.(2),the RTC can be got by taking derivatives ofρ(T) with respect to T.

For T≥θD,αis given by:

whereθD is the Debye temperature.This equation demonstrates thatαis negative if ST(2kF)>1.Therefore,the negative RTC of ribbon samples of Ni-Nb-Zr alloys means 2kF lies in the vicinity of Kp,corresponding to K value at the first peak of structure factor S(K).More precisely,the negative RTC means the relative difference(η) between 2kF and Kp,given by:

must satisfyη≤10%according to the extended ZimanFaber theory.

The width of the main Brillouin zone (Kp) can be obtained from XRD patterns using:

where 2θp is the Bragg diffraction angle corresponding to the first peak of structure factor S(K).Using Eqs.(5) and(6),the possible values of kF and EF of these Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses are calculated,as listed in Table 1.

3.3 Magnetic performance

Figure 3 shows the hysteresis M-H loops of the Ni-Nb-Zr ribbon samples under magnetic field up to 8×105A·m-1.The saturated moments are 0.175,0.125,0.050,and0.050 A·m2·kg-1 under high magnetic field for the Ni-NbZr amorphous samples Ni63.29Nb31.65Zr5.06,Ni62.5Nb32.75Zr4.75,Ni62.5Nb31.25Zr6.25,and Ni48Nb32Zr20.

Although the Ni-rich metallic glass Ni63.29Nb31.65Zr5.06has the highest saturated moment of 0.175 A·m2·kg-1 among these Ni-Nb-Zr ribbon samples,it is still a weak magnetic substance compared with most Fe-and Co-based magnetic metallic glasses [ 27] of which the saturated moment is about60 A·m2·kg-1.There are three major reasons for such low magnetic intensities of Ni-based metallic glass.First,among the three transition magnetic elements,Ni has the lowest atomic magnetic moment.Second,according to SlaterPauling rule [ 28, 29] of transition alloys,the average atomic magnetic moment is always shown as a function of the average atomic electron number.The electron numbers of Nb(41) and Zr(40) in Ni-Nb-Zr alloys are so large that highenergy electrons from Nb or Zr are likely to lower their energies and affect the 3d orbital of Ni.As a result,the average atomic magnetic moment is leveled.Among these Ni-Nb-Zr alloys,with the decrease in Ni content,the average atomic electron number decreases,so the decrease in magnetic intensities with Ni content decreasing is shown in Fig.3.The third reason is the decrease in exchange energy as a function of interatomic distance,causing low magnetic intensities of Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses.In the Ni-Nb-Zr system,the atomic radii of Nb and Zr are larger than that of Ni,while most of Fe-and Co-based magnetic metallic glasses contain some small-sized atoms,such as B.This phenomenon can also be found in Figs.3 and 4.For example,the Ni62.5Nb32.75Zr4.75 ([M-Ni6Nb4.24MZr0.76]Ni3) and Ni62.5Nb31.25Zr6.25 ([M-Ni6Nb4MZr1]Ni3) have same Ni content but show different magnetic properties.As Zr has a bigger atomic radius of 0.160 nm,the increase in Zr content could reduce the exchange interaction;consequently,the Ni62.5Nb31.25Zr6.25 shows a lower magnetic intensity compared with Ni62.5Nb32.75Zr4.75.Figure 4 shows the curves of intensity of magnetization with magnetic field intensity (M-H hysteresis loops) of the Ni63.29Nb31.65Zr5.06 amorphous ribbon sample at 10,150,and 300 K.The saturated moment increases from 0.175 to 0.182 A·m2·kg-1 with the decrease in temperature from 300 to 10 K.While the cold reduces the interatomic distance,the exchange interaction becomes stronger;consequently,the hysteresis M-H loops show a higher saturated moments at lower temperature.

  下载原图

Table 1 Calculated values corresponding to relation of 2kF and Kp

Fig.3 Magnetization curves of Ni-Nb-Zr samples under high magnetic field.Inset being detail of curves around origin of coordinates

Soft magnetic materials are defined as low coercivity(Hc<800 A·m-1) and high permeability.As shown in the insets of Figs.3 and 4,they all exhibit high coercivities.The coercivity(Hc) of Ni62.5Nb32.75Zr4.75,Ni62.5Nb31.25Zr6.25,and Ni48Nb32Zr20 are about 4000 A·m-1,while that of Ni63.29Nb31.65Zr5.06 is about 1000-2000 A·m-1 at different temperatures.

Fig.4 Magnetization curves of Ni63.29Nb31.65Zr5.06 at 10,150,and300 K.Inset being detail of curves around origin of coordinates

4 Conclusion

Ni-Nb-Zr ribbon samples with amorphous structure exhibit negative RTC in the temperature range of 77-293 K.Low-temperature drift with average RTC of 93×10-6-162×10-6 K-1 demonstrates that the Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses possess the prospects to become candidate for lowtemperature drift resistor used at low temperature from room temperature to 77 K.

The magnetic intensities of Ni-Nb-Zr metallic glasses decrease with the increases in average atomic electron number and the interatomic distance.The Ni-rich metallic glass Ni63.29Nb31.65Zr5.06 e×hibits the highest saturated moment of0.175 A·m2·kg-1 and the lowest coercivity of 2000 A·m-1among these Ni-Nb-Zr ribbon samples at 300 K.At 10 K,its s aturated moment reaches 0.182 A·m2·kg-1 and its coercivity decreases to~1000 A·m-1.

Acknowledgments This study was financially supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No.51171035) and the Doctor Research Start-Up Funding of Jiangsu University of Science and Technology (No.1062921406).

参考文献

[1] Shechtman D,Blech I,Gratias D,Cahn JW.Metallic phase with long-range orientational order and no translational symmetry.Phys Rev Lett.1984;53(20):1951.

[2] Ye HQ,Li DX,Kuo KH.Domain structures of tetrahedrally close-packed phases with juxtaposed pentagonal antiprisms I.Structure description and HREM images of the C14 laves andμphases.Philos Mag A.1985;51(6):829.

[3] Ye HQ,Wang DN,Kuo KH.Domain structures of tetrahedrally close-packed phases with juxtaposed pentagonal antiprisms II.Domain boundary structures of the CI4 Laves phase.Philos Mag A.1985;51(6):839.

[4] Zhao YC,Kou SZ,Yuan XP,Li CY,Yu P,Pu YL.Microstructure and mechanical properties of Cu46Zr44Al5Nb5 bulk amorphous alloy prepared with cooling rates.Chin J Rare Met.2014;38(2):171.

[5] Zhang W,Inoue A,Zhang T.Thermal stability and mechanical strength of bulk glassy Ni-Nb-Ti-Zr alloys.Mater Trans.2002;43(8):1952.

[6] Tien HY,Lin CY,Chin TS.New ternary Ni-Ta-Sn bulk metallic glasses.Intermetallics.2006;14(8-9):1075.

[7] Choi-Yim H,Xu D,Johnson WL.Ni-based bulk metallic glass formation in the Ni-Nb-Sn and Ni-Nb-Sn-X(X=B,Fe,Cu)alloy systems.Appl Phys Lett.2003;82(7):1030.

[8] Qiang JB,Yuan L,Wang Q,Wang YM,Dong C,Zhang W,Inoue A.Binary Ni-Ta bulk metallic glasses designed by using a cluster-plus-glue-atom model.Mater Sci Forum.2011;688(20):395.

[9] Li DK,Zhu ZW,Zhang HF,Wang AM,Hu ZQ.The influence of Zr substitution for Nb on the corrosion behaviors of the NiNb-Zr bulk metallic glasses.Sci.China-Phys Mech Astron.2012;55(12):2362.

[10] Jing Q,Zhang Y,Li Y.Composition optimization of the NiZrYAl glass forming alloys.J Alloys Compd.2006;424(1-2):307.

[11] Miracle DB.The efficient cluster packing model—an atomic structural model for metallic glasses.Acta Mater.2006;54(16):4317.

[12] Zhu ZW,Zhang HF,Ding BZ,Hu ZQ.Synthesis and properties of bulk metallic glasses in the ternary Ni-Nb-Zr alloy system.Mater Sci Eng A.2008;492(1-2):221.

[13] Yamaura SI,Sakurai M,Hasegawa M,Wakoh K,Shimpo Y,Nishida M,Kimura H,Matsubara E,Inoue A.Hydrogenpermeation and structural features of melt-spun Ni-Nb-Zr amorphous alloys.Acta Mater.2005;53(13):3703.

[14] Yuan L,Pang C,Wang YM,Wang Q,Qiang JB,Dong C.Understanding the Ni-Nb-Zr BMG composition from a binary eutectic Ni-Nb icosahedral cluster.Intermetallics.2010;18(10):1800.

[15] Dong C,Wang Q,Qiang JB,Wang YM,Jiang N,Han G,Li YH,Wu J,Xia JH.From clusters to phase diagrams:composition rules of quasicrystals and bulk metallic glasses.J Phys D Appl Phys.2007;40(15):R273.

[16] Chen JX,Wang Q,Wang YM,Qiang JB,Dong C.Cluster formulae for alloy phases.Philos Mag Lett.2010;90(9):683.

[17] Naugle DG,Delgado R,Armbr(u|¨)ster H,Tsai CL,Callaway TO,Reynolds D,Moruzzi VL.Electron transport in calcium-based metallic glasses.Phys Rev B.1986;34(12):8279.

[18] Freitag JM,Altounian Z.Electron transport properties of Al-YNi metallic glasses.Mater Sci Eng,A.1997;226(6):1053.

[19] Dyos GT,Farrell T.Electrical Resistivity Handbook.London:Peter Peregrinus Ltd;1992.50.

[20] Bai HY,Tong CZ,Zheng P.Electrical resistivity in Zr48Nb8Cu12Fe8Be24 glassy and crystallized alloys.J Appl Phys.2004;95(3):1269.

[21] Ziman JM.A theory of the electrical properties of liquid metals I:the monovalent metals.Philos Mag.1961;6(68):1013.

[22] Faber TE,Ziman JM.A theory of the electrical properties of liquid metals.Philos.Mag.1965;11(109):153.

[23] Evans R,Greenwood DA,Lloyd P.Calculations of the transport properties of liquid transition metals.Phys Lett A.1971;35(2):57.

[24] Nagel SR.Temperature dependence of the resistivity in metallic glasses.Phys Rev B.1977;16(4):1694.

[25] Meisel LV,Cote PJ.Application of the extended Ziman theory to amorphous nickel-phosphorus alloys.Phys Rev B.1977;15(6):2970.

[26] Nardi E.Plasma and liquid-metal resistivity calculations using the Ziman theory.Phys Rev E.1996;54(2):1899.

[27] Zhang JL,Wang YM,Shek HC.Design of soft magnetic CoSiB metallic glass with low Co contents.J Appl Phys.2011;110(8):083919.

[28] Slater JC.The ferromagnetism of nickel.Ⅱ.Temperature effects.Phys Rev.1936;49(12):931.

[29] Pauling L.The nature of the interatomic forces in metals.Phys Rev.1938;54(11):899.

[1] Shechtman D,Blech I,Gratias D,Cahn JW.Metallic phase with long-range orientational order and no translational symmetry.Phys Rev Lett.1984;53(20):1951.

[2] Ye HQ,Li DX,Kuo KH.Domain structures of tetrahedrally close-packed phases with juxtaposed pentagonal antiprisms I.Structure description and HREM images of the C14 laves andμphases.Philos Mag A.1985;51(6):829.

[3] Ye HQ,Wang DN,Kuo KH.Domain structures of tetrahedrally close-packed phases with juxtaposed pentagonal antiprisms II.Domain boundary structures of the CI4 Laves phase.Philos Mag A.1985;51(6):839.

[4] Zhao YC,Kou SZ,Yuan XP,Li CY,Yu P,Pu YL.Microstructure and mechanical properties of Cu46Zr44Al5Nb5 bulk amorphous alloy prepared with cooling rates.Chin J Rare Met.2014;38(2):171.

[5] Zhang W,Inoue A,Zhang T.Thermal stability and mechanical strength of bulk glassy Ni-Nb-Ti-Zr alloys.Mater Trans.2002;43(8):1952.

[6] Tien HY,Lin CY,Chin TS.New ternary Ni-Ta-Sn bulk metallic glasses.Intermetallics.2006;14(8-9):1075.

[7] Choi-Yim H,Xu D,Johnson WL.Ni-based bulk metallic glass formation in the Ni-Nb-Sn and Ni-Nb-Sn-X(X=B,Fe,Cu)alloy systems.Appl Phys Lett.2003;82(7):1030.

[8] Qiang JB,Yuan L,Wang Q,Wang YM,Dong C,Zhang W,Inoue A.Binary Ni-Ta bulk metallic glasses designed by using a cluster-plus-glue-atom model.Mater Sci Forum.2011;688(20):395.

[9] Li DK,Zhu ZW,Zhang HF,Wang AM,Hu ZQ.The influence of Zr substitution for Nb on the corrosion behaviors of the NiNb-Zr bulk metallic glasses.Sci.China-Phys Mech Astron.2012;55(12):2362.

[10] Jing Q,Zhang Y,Li Y.Composition optimization of the NiZrYAl glass forming alloys.J Alloys Compd.2006;424(1-2):307.

[11] Miracle DB.The efficient cluster packing model—an atomic structural model for metallic glasses.Acta Mater.2006;54(16):4317.

[12] Zhu ZW,Zhang HF,Ding BZ,Hu ZQ.Synthesis and properties of bulk metallic glasses in the ternary Ni-Nb-Zr alloy system.Mater Sci Eng A.2008;492(1-2):221.

[13] Yamaura SI,Sakurai M,Hasegawa M,Wakoh K,Shimpo Y,Nishida M,Kimura H,Matsubara E,Inoue A.Hydrogenpermeation and structural features of melt-spun Ni-Nb-Zr amorphous alloys.Acta Mater.2005;53(13):3703.

[14] Yuan L,Pang C,Wang YM,Wang Q,Qiang JB,Dong C.Understanding the Ni-Nb-Zr BMG composition from a binary eutectic Ni-Nb icosahedral cluster.Intermetallics.2010;18(10):1800.

[15] Dong C,Wang Q,Qiang JB,Wang YM,Jiang N,Han G,Li YH,Wu J,Xia JH.From clusters to phase diagrams:composition rules of quasicrystals and bulk metallic glasses.J Phys D Appl Phys.2007;40(15):R273.

[16] Chen JX,Wang Q,Wang YM,Qiang JB,Dong C.Cluster formulae for alloy phases.Philos Mag Lett.2010;90(9):683.

[17] Naugle DG,Delgado R,Armbr(u|¨)ster H,Tsai CL,Callaway TO,Reynolds D,Moruzzi VL.Electron transport in calcium-based metallic glasses.Phys Rev B.1986;34(12):8279.

[18] Freitag JM,Altounian Z.Electron transport properties of Al-YNi metallic glasses.Mater Sci Eng,A.1997;226(6):1053.

[19] Dyos GT,Farrell T.Electrical Resistivity Handbook.London:Peter Peregrinus Ltd;1992.50.

[20] Bai HY,Tong CZ,Zheng P.Electrical resistivity in Zr48Nb8Cu12Fe8Be24 glassy and crystallized alloys.J Appl Phys.2004;95(3):1269.

[21] Ziman JM.A theory of the electrical properties of liquid metals I:the monovalent metals.Philos Mag.1961;6(68):1013.

[22] Faber TE,Ziman JM.A theory of the electrical properties of liquid metals.Philos.Mag.1965;11(109):153.

[23] Evans R,Greenwood DA,Lloyd P.Calculations of the transport properties of liquid transition metals.Phys Lett A.1971;35(2):57.

[24] Nagel SR.Temperature dependence of the resistivity in metallic glasses.Phys Rev B.1977;16(4):1694.

[25] Meisel LV,Cote PJ.Application of the extended Ziman theory to amorphous nickel-phosphorus alloys.Phys Rev B.1977;15(6):2970.

[26] Nardi E.Plasma and liquid-metal resistivity calculations using the Ziman theory.Phys Rev E.1996;54(2):1899.

[27] Zhang JL,Wang YM,Shek HC.Design of soft magnetic CoSiB metallic glass with low Co contents.J Appl Phys.2011;110(8):083919.

[28] Slater JC.The ferromagnetism of nickel.Ⅱ.Temperature effects.Phys Rev.1936;49(12):931.

[29] Pauling L.The nature of the interatomic forces in metals.Phys Rev.1938;54(11):899.